The short answer
There is no single best floor for a Boise-area home. There is a best fit for each room. Luxury vinyl plank (LVP) is often the practical pick where water and pets are part of daily life. Laminate offers a hard, scratch-resistant surface, but its water resistance varies a lot by product. Hardwood is real wood, and depending on how it is made, it can be sanded and refinished years from now. LVP and laminate can’t.
How each one is built
LVP is a layered vinyl product: a printed design under a clear wear layer, usually listed in mils, on top of a core. Rigid-core products use a stone-plastic (SPC) or wood-plastic (WPC) core and usually click together. Thinner, flexible vinyl is often glued down.
Laminate puts a printed wood image under a hard, clear top layer, bonded to a core that has traditionally been high-density fiberboard. Most laminate clicks together and floats over an underlayment.
Solid hardwood is one piece of wood from top to bottom. Engineered hardwood is also real wood, built from bonded layers with a top layer of the species you choose, called the wear layer. Construction varies by product, so compare specifications, not just the name.
Water and moisture: read the fine print
Most rigid-core LVP is sold as waterproof, meaning the planks themselves won’t swell when water sits on them. That does not make the floor a moisture barrier. Armstrong Flooring’s FAQ notes that only the flooring material is waterproof, and that moisture can still affect the subfloor beneath and cause the installation to fail. Water can reach the subfloor through seams and edges, and moisture rising from a slab or crawl space can be trapped underneath.
Laminate varies by product. Traditional laminate with a fiberboard core can swell if water gets into the joints. Many newer products are sold as water-resistant for a stated number of hours. The North American Laminate Flooring Association (NALFA) certifies laminate against a set of performance tests, and offers an optional add-on surface swell test that simulates prolonged water exposure at the joints. If water matters, ask whether the product carries that add-on certification. Read what your warranty covers, because spills, standing water, wet mopping and full bathrooms are often treated differently.
Hardwood doesn’t like standing water either. Wipe spills promptly and pay attention near sinks, dishwashers and exterior doors.
Scratches, pets and everyday wear
Laminate’s hard top layer tends to resist scratches well. NALFA defines a scratch test meant to reflect damage from shoes, pets and grit. Many laminates also list an abrasion class, often shown as an AC rating.
LVP’s scratch resistance depends mostly on its wear layer and finish. Because the planks don’t swell, vinyl copes well with pet accidents that are cleaned up promptly.
Hardwood will collect dents and scratches over time, and softer species show them sooner. The upside is that a solid floor, or an engineered floor with enough wear layer, can be sanded and refinished instead of replaced. With any material, a lower-sheen finish and some natural color variation hide everyday marks better than a glossy, dark, uniform floor.
Comfort and sound
LVP usually feels a little softer and warmer underfoot than laminate. Floating floors of either kind can sound more hollow than a floor fastened to the subfloor, and laminate can have a sharper click underfoot. An attached pad, or an underlayment where the manufacturer allows one, helps. Nail-down or glue-down hardwood tends to feel the most solid.
Refinishing: where real wood is different
LVP and laminate can’t be sanded. Badly worn or damaged planks get replaced, so keep a box of spares from the same production run.
NWFA’s installation guidelines note that solid wood floors can be sanded and refinished numerous times during their service life. Engineered wood depends on its wear layer. To qualify for NWFA’s refinishable program, factory-finished engineered flooring needs a wear layer of at least 2.5 mm (3/32 inch). If refinishing someday matters to you, ask for the wear layer thickness in millimeters and whether the manufacturer says it can be sanded.
Already have hardwood that looks tired? Hardwood floor refinishing may be worth considering before you replace it.
How it goes down: floating, glue-down or nail-down
Floating floors, which include most laminate and rigid-core LVP, click together and rest on the subfloor without being fastened. They need expansion space at the walls and may need breaks at doorways or on long runs. Many shouldn’t be pinned under a kitchen island, so the order of work matters in a remodel.
Glue-down installation is common for thinner, flexible vinyl and for some engineered wood over concrete. Nail-down or staple-down is the traditional method for solid hardwood over a wood subfloor.
Every method depends on the subfloor. Manufacturers set flatness tolerances, and dips that old carpet hid can make joints flex. NWFA’s guidelines call for moisture testing concrete before any wood floor goes down, solid or engineered, and say solid wood shouldn’t be installed below grade unless the manufacturer recommends it. Engineered wood can generally go above, on or below grade. Vinyl and laminate instructions set their own moisture limits.
Acclimation rules are product-specific. NWFA describes it as matching the wood’s moisture content to normal living conditions rather than waiting a fixed number of days. Vinyl and laminate makers set their own rules, so follow the instructions for your exact product.
What the Treasure Valley climate means for your floor
The Boise area is dry for much of the year, and humidity swings with the seasons. Western Regional Climate Center data for Boise (1996 to 2010) show average afternoon relative humidity of about 21 to 23 percent in July and August, and about 68 percent in December and January. Those are outdoor readings. Cold winter air holds little moisture, so heating it indoors drops its relative humidity well below the outdoor figure. In a heated home, winter is usually the driest time of year, and NWFA notes that this dry season is when wood floors can gap and some engineered floors can dry-cup.
NWFA explains that wood swells as it gains moisture and shrinks as it loses it, and that small gaps which open and close with the seasons are normal. It recommends keeping your home between 60 and 80°F and 30 to 50 percent relative humidity year-round, which may mean using a humidifier. A simple hygrometer shows where your home sits.
LVP is less affected by humidity than wood, but it reacts to sun and heat. Armstrong notes that UV rays can discolor vinyl and suggests closing blinds or curtains on very sunny days. Its rigid-core installation guide adds that some products call for adhesive where expansion from strong sunlight is a risk. Sun affects wood as well: NWFA notes that some species lighten or darken with exposure to light. This matters most in rooms with large south- or west-facing windows.
Thinking about resale
There is no universal answer on value. Real wood has long been seen as a premium finish, and a refinishable floor can be refreshed before listing. Well-made LVP and laminate are common in remodeled homes and often seen as practical. One continuous floor through the main living areas usually reads better than several products meeting at every doorway. If you plan to sell soon, ask a local real estate agent what buyers in your neighborhood expect.
Room by room
A starting point, not a rule: the exact product and what’s underneath it decide. For wet areas and shower floors, compare tile as well.
| Room | Often a good fit | Check first |
|---|---|---|
| Kitchen | LVP or water-resistant laminate. Engineered or solid hardwood if you are happy to wipe spills promptly. | Warranty water terms, whether an island will sit on a floating floor, and the transition to the next room. |
| Bathrooms | LVP approved for full baths, or tile. | Whether the product is approved for a bathroom with a tub or shower, and any perimeter sealing it requires. |
| Basement or below grade | LVP, or engineered wood approved for below grade. | A moisture test on the concrete and any vapor barrier the manufacturer specifies. Solid wood only if its manufacturer recommends it there. |
| Living areas | Any of the three. | Direct sun (vinyl can expand or discolor; some wood species change color), long runs that may need breaks, and one continuous look through connected rooms. |
| Bedrooms | Any of the three. | Comfort underfoot and, upstairs, sound traveling to the rooms below. |
| Pets and kids | LVP or laminate with a strong wear rating. Hardwood if you accept some marks and may refinish later. | Wear layer or abrasion rating, how the warranty treats accidents and spills, and a lower-sheen finish. |
| Stairs | Hardwood treads, or LVP or laminate with matching stair nosing. | That the product line makes stair parts. Planks on stairs are fastened or glued, not floated. |
Questions to ask before you choose
- Is this exact product approved for this room and this subfloor, including concrete or below grade?
- What does the warranty say about spills, standing water, wet mopping and full bathrooms?
- How durable is the top surface: wear layer in mils for LVP, abrasion class (AC rating) for laminate, wear layer in millimeters for engineered wood?
- How will the subfloor be checked for flatness and moisture, and what happens if it needs work?
- Will it float, be glued or be nailed, and how will it meet cabinets, stairs and the next room?
- What temperature and humidity range does the manufacturer require, and does it call for acclimation?
- Does the line include matching stair nosing and transitions, and can I keep spare planks?
New to terms like transition profiles? Our materials in plain English guide explains them.
Have a project in mind?
Share the rooms you want to change and your Greater Boise location. Let’s talk through which floor fits.
Start your project